Saturday, December 6, 2008

Discussion Questions for Chapter 4 - due Tuesday, 12/9

Post your discussion questions here. Be sure to review the previously posted questions before posting your own.

34 comments:

Najha said...

What do you think Mackail means when he/she writes " The gods are angry; we shall never be Now as of old," What does it mean "we shall never be Now as of old" ?

Julian Rivera said...

Why did Zeus with Prometheus even though Zeus knew he could not be trusted with not giving Man fire?
Did Zeus want to test Prometheus' temptations?
Do you think Zeus wanted to find a way to punish P.?
Why or why not?

Sara Galeano said...

Do you think Hermes knew that Mankind would be spared because Deucalion and Pyrrha weren't wicked people?
Do you think that meeting Philemon and Baucis made an impact on Zeus's opinions about man? ahy or why not?
Do you think Zeus is basically lost without Prometheus's wisdom?

eminem said...

do you think that zuez was right to destroy the villages they went to. if not then what should have he done

austen said...

What do you think the flood represented? Why?

Zoya said...

Do you think that Zeus was right to punish Prometheus instead of the humans? After all, they accepted his gift when they knew that Zeus would be mad. Should the humans have protested the banishment of their maker?

Noah said...

"You see, men are as wicked as I thought," said Zeus. What does this mean? Why did Zeus say this and what does it say about his character?

S H Y guy N101 said...

Do you think Prometheus deserved the punishment that Zeus gave him?
Why?

Do you think Hermes set up their last visit so that mortals would live?
Why?

eleanor mcgrath said...

if zues wasn't so bossy and didn't have such a bad temper do you think that mother earth wouldn't have unleashed the monsters?

Lucas said...

What does the fact that all the wicked men were destroyed say about the ancient greeks who created this story?
How does the way the ancient greeks thought about themsleves affect the story?

Rodrigo9112 said...

Are the bible and the ancient myths related in any type of way? If so how much? Do they contradict each other?

Unknown said...

Do you think that the Greeks believed that Zeus came down to Earth more than once to survey man and decide whether or not another magical flood would be needed?

sophie said...

Why did Zeus turn Lycaon into a wolf? Wolves sense of no family reminds makes me wonder if thery were frowned upon. Were certain animals desired more than others? Is this where the myth that wolves are evil started? If so, what does this say for the humans and gods? What does it say about that particular religions?

Unknown said...

what do you think this story is similar to? How do you think think the antient Greeks came up with the story of a great flood to wipe all evil from Greece? Do you think this story was based off of another story? If so, which story and what do they have in common?

PETER V. said...

whoes side is mother nature on anyway?

how was the flood the differnce betwen what makes a hero from the hero age and good person from the bronse age? what makes them a hero that they didn't have before?

Kelsey Barbosa said...

Do you think that Zeus told Deucalion and Pyrrha to throw the stones because he thought that was Prometheus is secret or just to restart mankind? why?

Adin Levy said...

What does Mother Earth releasing monsters into the world symbolize for the ancient greek culture?

Janet.O said...

Besides the fact to test the human, why do you tyhink Hermes and Zues went down to earth? what do you think the race of mankind has heard about the gods in order to distingiush them?

erika said...

Why are these myths somewhat similar to christian stories? (ex. Noahs Ark, Adam and Eve)

How do you think Zeuses future will be without Prometheus?

Unknown said...

Why did the story of Zeus and hermes include a story very similar to the story of "Noah's Ark"? Was this done on purpose or accidental?

-Katherina

Tyra said...

What do you think the relashionship between Zeus and Prometheus is?
Do you think there it's a give and take or a betrayal relashionship?
How do you think this shows in Chapter 4?
How do you think this relashionship impacts there personalities and perspectives?
--------------------------------
Do you think the flood changed the mood of the book?

Thamyr.D said...

Do you think that Zeus is trying to be cruel to the humans or think other whys? why or why not

kabanzzz said...

Do zeus and Promentheus have a bad relationship or was there an incident in the past that made him give promentheus fire? Did Zeus want to find a way to hurt Promentheus, did he know that he would give the mortals fire?

sophie said...

By the way this is Rex: My account doesn't work

In ancient Greece, it is known that people from different cities lived far apart from each other. Also, they are mostly belligerent and often raged wars. What does this scenario influence the storytellers, and how much power to philosophers and religious orders hold in Greece?

MaiteCaballero said...

Do you think the outcome would have been different if Prometheous was there? Why or why why not? Does your awnser have anything t do withthe fact that he created humans? How so?

djuna mks said...

What does the story of the flood remind you of in the Old Testament?

♥ fashionG33K ♥ said...

Because Nyctimus refused to eat human flesh, Lycaon killed him. Even though Zeus was disguised as a old man, why wouldnt he stop this scene?

♥ Emma Francesca ♥

itai said...

do u think greek mythology is like other religions

Ife said...

If Zeus has an extreme disliking of humans, why doesn't he just get rid of them instead of just giving them chance after chance and they fail him?

matt said...

Why do you think Zeus had become more compassionate in the time following Prometheus and Pandora?

Punto said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Punto said...

How do you think the story of Hermes and Zeus connect to Noah's Ark? What does it show about religions and the connections of our histories?

--Emilie

daniel said...

Do you think Zues learned not to judge humans before getting to know them? How could this change the way zues looks at humans?

englishkid said...

Why did Zeus have need to destroy the human race and why did Hermes want to save them? (this was previously posted 12/8 as a comment on the homework page)